The Quitman Police Department is taking a fresh look at the 1990 murder of former Quitman High School teacher Deborah Herrington, officially reopening the cold case during a press conference Tuesday, Nov. 10.
Police Chief Chris Read said the department has spent several months reviewing the case and recently received new information through social media, prompting investigators to prioritize the more than 36-year-old case.
“It's about getting closure for the victim's family, for the friends, associates, the citizens of this community,” Read said.
Herrington, 36, was stabbed to death in her home on Jan. 2, 1990. She was found the following day after failing to report to school following Christmas break. No one has ever been charged in her death.
Assistant Chief Edwin Laws will lead the investigation, with Read remaining actively involved. The Clarke County Sheriff's Department is also assisting.
One of the department's primary goals is locating and reviewing physical and DNA evidence collected at the original crime scene. Read said some evidence remains preserved at the state crime laboratory in Jackson, where testing was conducted over several years, with the last known submission in 2011.
Previous reports indicated that male and female DNA profiles not belonging to Herrington were identified. However, Read said investigators have encountered conflicting information in the case records and are awaiting complete laboratory documentation to clarify the findings.
Read said investigators have recently spoken with individuals involved in the original investigation and are revisiting witness statements and persons of interest. He emphasized that rumors and speculation are not enough to support an arrest or conviction.
“We can’t arrest and convict based on what we think and who we think,” Read said, stressing the importance of physical evidence, DNA or a confession.
After more than three decades without an arrest, Quitman investigators are hoping renewed attention, advances in DNA technology and help from the public will bring answers in Herrington's death.
“Any information that you give is important to us, and it's new to us,” Read said. “We're going to continue to do that.”
Investigators are asking anyone with information, regardless of how insignificant it may seem, to come forward.
Information can be provided to Assistant Chief Edwin Laws by emailing edwinlawsqpd@gmail.com, calling 601-776-4015 or reaching him on his cell phone at 601-766-5545. Tips may also be provided directly to Read or through the department's social media accounts. Individuals do not have to provide their names.